The has not been able to verify the exact cause of his referral to the GMC, but the Guardian has reported it followed a complaint from Great Ormond Street Hospital, which, the newspaper said, had terminated his contract the year before.
According to guidance issued by the CPS in 2022, if information is received that “casts doubt on the competence and/or credibility of an expert witness… the disclosure implications need to be considered”.
It adds “the methodology used by the expert may be discredited” and “such information may render past convictions unsafe”.
The guidance adds: “In deciding whether action is needed in such cases, the overriding principle to be considered is public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system.”
The has asked the CPS whether it had any plans to refer the use of Hindmarsh as an expert witness in the Letby prosecution to its director of legal services.
No response has been received.
The CPS said regulatory investigations were separate and independent of criminal proceedings, and the existence of an investigation did not determine whether evidence was admissible or reliable.
According to the Guardian, Letby’s defence team, when initially told of the investigation into Hindmarsh, did not make an application to put the information before the jury because the CPS had said it would oppose it.
The opposition was said to be because the GMC had not reached a final conclusion.
The Guardian reported the CPS had seemingly not been told of a previous tribunal ruling and that Hindmarsh had been barred from treating patients.
The investigation into Hindmarsh never concluded because, according to GMC records, he “relinquished” his registration in November 2024 through a process known as “voluntary erasure”.
The GMC has not responded to the ‘s request for comment.
