WATCH: Peter Tatchell and Jacob Rees Mogg debate the conversion therapy bill
|
Published:
1794885280
| Updated:
1794885280
Baroness Hilary Cass has reversed her position on Labour’s draft Conversion Practices Bill, telling MPs the legislation risks “serious unintended consequences”.
The crossbench peer, whose review of children’s gender services transformed NHS prescribing of puberty blockers, had initially offered supportive remarks when the draft law was published in June.
However, she told the parliamentary committee scrutinising the bill that she had only one hour to review the legislation before the government sought a quote for its press release, and that she was 15 minutes away from delivering a speech at the time.
She said: “Having obviously spent a long time now thinking about it, I unfortunately don’t think that it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.”
When asked directly whether she still backed the bill, she simply said “no”.
Baroness Cass raised particular alarm about the prospect of “vexatious” complaints being lodged against clinicians working with gender-distressed young people, noting that the bill failed to adequately define what standards medical professionals should meet in such a contested field.
She said: “There are people who commit suicide whilst awaiting the outcome of a GMC referral. So the chilling effect isn’t theoretical, it’s real and it’s here today.”
She also flagged the danger that parents could be drawn into the legislation’s scope, for instance, by declining to use a child’s preferred pronouns or withholding money over concerns it might be spent on breast binders or hormones.
She said: “I know there’s absolutely not the intent for them to be caught up in this, but that is unavoidably potentially the risk of the way in which the bill is framed.”
The draft bill, which covers England and Wales, would impose prison sentences of up to five years and unlimited fines on those found guilty of pressuring others to change their sexual orientation or gender identity.
Labour pledged to outlaw conversion practices in its 2024 manifesto, though the issue has a far longer political history.
The first commitment to introduce such a ban came from Theresa May in 2018, with successive prime ministers, including Boris Johnson, who described the practice as “abhorrent”, making similar promises without delivering legislation.
Repeated delays were fuelled in part by disagreement over whether any prohibition should extend to gender identity as well as sexual orientation.
When equalities minister Olivia Bailey unveiled the draft law in June, she said it would “prevent and protect” LGBT+ people from abusive attempts to alter who they are.
Clinical psychologist Dr Anna Hutchinson told the parliamentary committee that across her extensive career working with young people exploring their gender identity, she had “never heard of any experience of abusive conversion practices as described by this Bill”.
Dr Lisa Morrison of the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy similarly told MPs her organisation was “not aware of any complaints that have solely focused or covered conversion practices”.
More than 1,000 church leaders have spoken out against the legislation, while the Catholic Church has urged politicians to abandon it entirely.
Baroness Kishwer Falkner, the former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, branded the bill “ill-conceived” and potentially “unworkable” in a recent Policy Exchange report.
Director of the Gay Men’s Network Dennis Kavanagh described Lady Cass’s withdrawal of support as “damning” and called the legislation “tyrannical and poorly drafted”, urging the government to scrap it entirely.
Maya Forstater, chief executive of gender-critical activist group Sex Matters, said the intervention was “arguably the most important” on the bill so far, adding that it was “hard to see how the bill can now feasibly progress”.
A government spokesman told the BBC: “We want to get this ban right, which is why we have put this draft bill forward for pre-legislative scrutiny.
“We welcome both Baroness Cass’s support for taking action to end abusive conversion practices and her comments on the need for legislation to avoid adverse consequences.
“We will take all evidence put forward by the committee seriously as we move forward in ending almost a decade of delay for LGBT+ people who should never have to suffer abuse in an effort to change who they are.”
The committee hearings continue.
Follow related topics:
`;
placeholder.insertAdjacentHTML(‘beforeend’, taboola);
}

