EXCLUSIVEConverted churches make divine homes: What they cost – and what buyers must look out for

Church conversion properties offer buyers an impressive exterior, high ceilings and multiple large windows. 

Each building is unique, and gives buyers the chance to own a home brimming with character and quirks, far more so than can be found in any new-build.

We look at how much you might pay for your own heavenly home, and take a look at three examples on the market right now. 

How much is a converted church home? 

The uniqueness of church conversions often comes at a premium. 

Buyers looking for a three-bedroom church conversion can expect to pay 30.8 per cent more for a church conversion than a traditional property.

In research from OnTheMarket seen exclusively by This is Money, data showed that a three-bedroom church conversion typically costs £554,015, against £405,975 for a conventional three-bed home. 

Four-bedroom church conversion homes typically cost £700,806, while traditional homes with the same number of bedrooms cost around £622,799, OnTheMarket said. 

However, for smaller properties, it could even be more cost effective to buy a church conversion over a conventional home. 

At £247,575, the cost of a one-bedroom church conversion is typically 4.1 per cent lower than a standard one-bedroom property. 

According to OnTheMarket’s research, Kew and Mill Hill in London and Caterham in Surrey are the three most expensive areas to buy a church conversion, with average prices in Kew reaching nearly £3million. 

At the other end of the market, Stockport, Newport and Bristol are the cheapest areas to buy a church conversion, with costs coming in at £172,450, £374,000 and £411,428 respectively. 

With converted churches being relatively rare, the averages will depend on what is on the market at that time.  

OnTheMarket said the locations with the highest number of church conversion properties on sale were London, Bristol and Stockport. 

What to watch for when buying a church conversion

While appealing, buying and living in a church conversion will not always be straightforward. 

Churches can come with all kinds of quirks, and prospective buyers need to get a comprehensive survey carried out before taking the plunge. 

Matt Thompson, head of sales at Chestertons, told This is Money: ‘Often benefiting from impressive exteriors, high ceilings and large statement windows, converted churches are sought-after homes with a considerable fan base. 

‘Due to their popularity, these properties tend to receive multiple offers when put up for sale and find a new owner fairly quickly. 

‘Asking prices can vary and depend on the finish of the conversion, the property’s location and its overall condition.’

He added: ‘As the majority of churches are older buildings, a survey is crucial to identify any fundamental problems such as structural weaknesses. 

‘We also advise buyers to bear in mind that any desired work such as extensions could be restricted if the property has listed building status.’

Georgia Jakstys, an associate at Knight Frank, added: ‘Converted churches appeal to those seeking unconventional properties with unique character.’

‘One is likely, however, to be faced with service charges if you buy an apartment within a conversion, a lack of accessibility, or the inability to renovate if the building is listed. 

‘Despite this, church conversions are typically situated in easily accessible, central locations, often close to transport links and local amenities as they were designed to be community centres. 

‘Essentially, converted churches offer a special living experience that combines old-world charm with contemporary functionality, appealing to those who want a home that stands out from standard residential offerings. 

‘They are typically seen to be purchased by end users or accidental landlords rather than investors or developers.’       

Converted churches for sale 

This is Money reveals a selection of striking church conversion properties on sale now. 

First impressions count and this four-bedroom church conversion house in Temple, Midlothian, on sale via OnTheMarket and McEwan Fraser Legal for offers over £650,000, creates a good one. 

This nineteenth century converted church has four spacious bedrooms, a spiral staircase and a recording studio. Some notable artists have reportedly recorded in the studio. 

As well as ample space indoors, the property comes with large grounds, parking and an EV charging station point. 

The current owners have happily lived in the property for many years.  

St Hilda’s House, a converted chapel, is located is the village of Caldwell in North Yorkshire and is on sale via Anthony Jones Properties for offers over £425,000. 

The property has an 180-year history and, internally, blends period features with luxury modern living. 

Internally, the property is impressive, boasting bespoke hardwood doors and a bespoke staircase. There are exposed stone walls and timber beams in the galleried landing. Every room has been finished to a high standard. 

Externally, a newly created private pathway leads to a secluded courtyard-style garden, perfect for alfresco dining. 

This three-bedroom converted chapel in Richmond is located in the heart of the Yorkshire Dales National Park and on sale for £595,000. 

There are stained glass windows, alcoves and stone flooring leading into an inner hall  on the ground floor. 

The living room is an L-shaped room with a dual aspect, including stained glass windows to the side and rear, a multi-fuel stove with a slate hearth and oak beam above.

The converted chapel is approached through wrought iron gates to both stone paved pathways and an opening to a gravelled area, providing parking for two or three vehicles.